The Piezotome in Endodontic Surgery
By Dr. Jean Philippe Mallett
Micro Endodontic Surgery is an essential intervention for addressing persistent infections or pathologies at the root apex of a tooth when conventional root canal therapy has proven unsuccessful. Traditionally, this procedure relied on invasive methods involving rotary instruments and handpieces to remove bone and access the apical region of the root. However, technological advancements over the past decade have significantly enhanced the precision, efficiency, and overall patient experience associated with these surgeries.
A notable innovation in this field is the Piezotome, an ultrasonic device specifically designed for precise bone cutting. The Piezotome has emerged as a transformative instrument in Micro Endodontic Surgery, offering numerous advantages over traditional surgical approaches. This paper examines the role of the Piezotome in apical endodontic surgery, detailing its mechanisms, benefits, and its impact on clinical outcomes and patient care.
Planning for Endodontic Surgery
To appreciate the significance of the Piezotome, it is essential to understand the framework of Micro Endodontic Surgery. This procedure is indicated for the treatment of persistent periapical lesions, cysts, or other pathologies localized at the root apex. Its primary objective is the thorough cleaning and sealing of the apical portion of the root to prevent further infection and promote bone regeneration.
Micro Endodontic Surgery encompasses procedures such as root-end resection, retrograde root filling, and debridement of periapical tissues. These interventions necessitate meticulous removal of bone, tissue, and the root apex, requiring high precision and minimal trauma to surrounding structures. To achieve optimal outcomes, a preoperative Cone Beam Computed Tomography (CBCT) analysis is essential for detailed anatomical assessment, and the surgery is performed under magnification using an operative microscope (1).
The Piezotome: A Technological Breakthrough
The Piezotome is an ultrasonic device specifically designed for bone cutting. Unlike traditional rotary instruments, it uses high-frequency ultrasonic vibrations to selectively cut mineralized tissues while sparing soft tissues. Its cutting mechanism is based on piezoelectricity, wherein electrical energy is converted into mechanical oscillations. These oscillations power a specialized tip, enabling precise and controlled bone cutting.
Key Components:
- Handpiece: Houses ultrasonic elements for vibration generation.
- Tips: Customizable for various surgical applications.
- Generator: Produces ultrasonic frequencies.
This design allows the Piezotome to preserve critical structures like nerves, blood vessels, and periodontal ligaments, making it invaluable in apical surgery.
Key Contributions of the Piezotome
1. Precision and Minimally Invasive Surgery
The Piezotome excels in accessing root apices in restricted or challenging areas. Its ability to minimize damage to surrounding tissues reduces complications such as bleeding and delayed healing. By preserving bone integrity, it facilitates retrograde fillings and accelerates recovery.(2)
2. Reduced Bleeding and Enhanced Visibility
Ultrasonic vibrations create a micro-cavitation effect, ensuring a blood-free surgical field. This effect minimizes the need for hemostatic agents like ferric sulfate. Additionally, cavitation disrupts bacterial cell walls, providing antibacterial benefits. (3)
3. Reduced Thermal Damage
Traditional instruments, such as drills and burs, generate heat that can damage bones and surrounding tissues, leading to complications. In contrast, the Piezotome operates at lower temperatures with constant irrigation, preventing thermal necrosis of vital structures like the periodontal ligament, soft tissues and bones.(4)
4. Improved Access and Surgical Control
The integration of the Piezotome with magnification tools, such as surgical loupes or microscopes, significantly enhances the precision of apical surgery. Clear visibility of the surgical site is critical for accurate cutting and tissue removal. The Piezotome's fine tip and ultrasonic vibration mechanism effectively reduce debris and heat generation during surgery, ensuring a clearer and more controlled surgical field.
One of the primary challenges in apical surgery is navigating the complex anatomies of root canals. Teeth with curved or dilacerated roots often make accessing the apical area difficult while preserving surrounding structures. Compared to rotary handpieces, the Piezotome's deflected tip and precise cutting capabilities provide easier access to the apex without compromising the integrity of the tooth or adjacent bone.
Moreover, the Piezotome proves particularly advantageous in procedures like granuloma removal. Such procedures often require delicate maneuvering in confined spaces, and the Piezotome's round, diamond-coated tip with controlled vibrations enables a level of precision that is challenging to achieve with handheld or rotary instruments.
5. Bony Lid Technique
On lower molar surgeries with a thick buccal bone plate or in endodontic procedures near the Schneiderian membrane of the sinus or the alveolar nerve, increased bone removal is often necessary to visualize anatomical structures, protect them, and access the lesion effectively. (5)(6)
The bony lid technique, proposed for apicoectomies, involves creating a window in the bone to form a removable lid. This lid is carefully extracted and preserved in an isotonic saline or Hanks solution to facilitate the microsurgical procedure. Once the procedure is completed, the lid is repositioned and secured using platelet-rich fibrin (PRF) or a collagen membrane. An additional advantage of this technique is its ability to limit the invasion of periodontal cells, thereby promoting more effective bone healing.
The use of the Piezotome to create the bony lid ensures a precise, thin, and non-heated osteotomy cut. This minimizes bone loss, reduces trauma, and simplifies the repositioning and stabilization of the lid, enhancing surgical outcomes (8)
6. Enhanced Patient Comfort and Faster Recovery
The minimally invasive nature of Piezotome-assisted surgery significantly enhances patient comfort both during and after the procedure. By reducing bone removal and minimizing trauma to soft tissues, it results in less postoperative pain, swelling, and discomfort compared to traditional methods. (7) Additionally, the Piezotome’s highly controlled cutting action minimizes the risk of unintentional damage to surrounding tissues, which can otherwise lead to complications and prolong the healing process.
Moreover, the precision of the Piezotome enables smaller incisions, streamlining the surgical procedure and reducing its overall invasiveness. These combined benefits contribute to faster recovery times, fewer complications, and improved patient satisfaction, ultimately increasing the overall success rate of the surgery.
Supporting Clinical Evidence
Numerous clinical studies have assessed the effectiveness of the Piezotome in endodontic surgery, emphasizing its advantages over traditional methods. One study revealed that patients undergoing Piezotome-assisted apical surgery experienced significantly less postoperative pain and swelling compared to those treated with conventional rotary instruments. Furthermore, the Piezotome group demonstrated superior bone preservation, faster healing, and fewer complications, such as bone resorption or nerve damage. (3)
Additional research has shown that the application of ultrasonic technology in root-end resections enhances the precision of apical resections and retrograde fillings. This results in higher success rates and improved long-term outcomes for patients. These findings highlight the growing body of evidence affirming the Piezotome’s value as an essential tool in modern endodontic surgery. (9)
Conclusion
The Piezotome has transformed apical endodontic surgery by providing a more precise, minimally invasive, and highly controlled alternative to conventional surgical instruments. Its capability to excise bone with minimal disruption to adjacent tissues, reduced thermal impact, and improved patient comfort underscores its significance in contemporary endodontic practice. By enhancing access to the root apex, preserving osseous structures, and expediting recovery, the Piezotome has substantially improved clinical outcomes and patient satisfaction.
With ongoing advancements in technology, the Piezotome is poised to assume an increasingly pivotal role in endodontic surgery, refining procedural accuracy and efficiency while mitigating the inherent risks of apical interventions. These distinct advantages position the Piezotome as a critical innovation in the evolution of endodontic methodologies and the comprehensive management of periapical pathology.
1. CBCT analysis 2. Pre and post op Rx 3. Operative site 4. Cutting the Bony Lid 5. Bony Lid removed 6. Root canal US preparation 7. Observation 8. Bony Lid stabilized 9. Main Piezo Inserts
Bibliography
1: S.C. Setzer S.I Krachtman, Presents status and futures directions : Surgical endodontics, IEJ 2022 (55):1020-1058
2: Abella F. et col: Applications of Piezoelectric Surgery in Endodontic Surgery: A literature Review.- JOE 40 (3) Mars 2014
3 : Bharathi J. et col: Effect of the Piezoelectric Device on Intraoperative Hemorrhage Control and Quality of Life after Endodontic Microsurgery:
A randomized Clinical Study- JOE 47 (7) July 2021
4: P. MAURER, et Al: Light Microscopic examination of rabbit skulls following conventional and Piezosurgery Osteotomy: Biomed Tech Oct 52 (5) 351:5 – 2007
5: K. Degerliyurt et al Bone Lid technique with piezosurgery to preserve inferior alveolar nerve. 000 108(6) 1-5 2009
6: Su-Min Lee, et all: The application of « Bone Window Technique » in Endodontic Microsurgery / JOE 2020
7: Goyal et al : Comparative evaluation of surgical outcome after removal of impacted mandibular third molars using a Piezotome or a conventional handpiece, BBJOMS 50 (2012)
8: Chen Bi et all : Endodontic Microsurgery of Mandibular second molars using the Bony lid Approach: A Case Series. JOE 2022 Dec 48 (12) 1533-1538
9: Sivolella S et all The Bony Lid Technique in Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery: A Scoping Review J Clin Med 2022 Jun 24; 11 (13) 3667